During the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, China, the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia held their first-ever trilateral meeting on November 19. US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin sat together for nearly 70 minutes. Prior to this joint gathering, President Trump had also held separate bilateral meetings with both Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. This high-profile encounter was considered momentous for global politics, given the long-standing differences among these three nations concerning trade, energy, nuclear arms, and international security.
Historic Summit and Statements by Leaders
US President Donald Trump described this gathering as a historic meeting, while Chinese President Xi Jinping termed the discussions positive and useful. Russian President Vladimir Putin stated that all three nations share a common responsibility to maintain global peace. However, this meeting failed to produce any concrete agreements regarding halting the wars in Ukraine and Iran or controlling nuclear weapons. The four-point joint declaration issued after the summit demonstrated an expressed desire for cooperation, but lacked any specific timelines or concrete targets.
Four Key Takeaways from the Trilateral Summit
During this historic meeting, the three leaders reached a consensus on four primary issues. These included reforming the United Nations (UN), increasing global oil supplies, questioning the powers of the International Criminal Court (ICC), and engaging in talks to reduce threats associated with nuclear weapons.
- Consensus on United Nations Reforms: The three nations emphasized that the United Nations must be restructured in a way that enables it to better address new global challenges and play a more effective role in maintaining international peace. The United States, China, and Russia are permanent members of the UN Security Council, giving each of them the power to veto any major resolution. However, the joint statement did not specify what exact changes they seek within the United Nations.
- Decision to Increase Global Oil Supplies: The three leaders agreed to boost the production and supply of petroleum products. They asserted that stable energy supplies remain in the best interest of all nations globally. This decision is also directly linked to the Iran conflict and the Strait of Hormuz. Trump and Xi had previously discussed their shared interest in keeping oil supplies flowing through this route, although the official joint declaration does not explicitly mention Iran or Hormuz.
- Questioning the International Criminal Court: The three countries stated that state sovereignty, consent, and the legal immunities granted to officials must be fully respected. They noted that the International Criminal Court (ICC) and similar institutions should not abuse their jurisdiction. This issue holds particular significance for President Putin, as the ICC has issued an arrest warrant against him over alleged unlawful deportation of Ukrainian children to Russia. Meanwhile, the United States has also imposed sanctions on the ICC and some of its officials due to actions involving America and its ally Israel. However, the joint declaration did not include any decision to withdraw from the ICC or alter its existing legal framework.
- Talks to Reduce Nuclear Weapon Threats: The three nations reiterated that a nuclear war can never be won and must never be fought. They agreed to engage in discussions to curb the proliferation of nuclear weapons and mitigate associated risks. The United States, Russia, and China are the world's largest nuclear powers, with the US and Russia holding over 5,000 nuclear weapons each, while China possesses more than 600. Nevertheless, the meeting yielded no agreement to reduce the number of nuclear warheads, nor were dates set for future talks. Notably, the New START treaty, the last major nuclear arms control pact between the US and Russia, expired in February 2026, and President Trump aims for a new pact that includes China.
No Consensus on the Wars in Ukraine and Iran
The most significant shortcoming of the summit was the failure to find a shared pathway to halt the two major global conflicts. President Trump had earlier stated that he would discuss the issues of Ukraine and Iran with Xi and Putin. He also sought China's cooperation in ending the Ukraine war, but President Xi didn't publicly endorse his proposal.
The joint declaration made no mention whatsoever of Ukraine or Iran. On top of that, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European nations were excluded from this summit, despite bearing the direct and profound impact of the war in Ukraine. This raised international questions regarding how any settlement concerning Ukraine's future could be negotiated without its participation.
Trump's Diplomacy and Xi's Diplomatic Gains
During the summit, President Trump placed immense emphasis on his personal relationships with Xi and Putin. Referring to Chinese President Xi as his friend, he stated that the two nations share a special relationship, while he also warmly welcomed Russian President Putin. This encounter yielded a diplomatic advantage for China, as President Xi showcased Beijing's elevated international standing by hosting leaders from the world's three major powers. Concurrently, President Vladimir Putin secured an opportunity to share a stage with the US President amid severe ongoing tensions with Western nations.
However, this growing closeness by President Trump could heighten anxieties among America's traditional European allies, many of whom have continuously sought to isolate Moscow internationally following Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Incomplete Trade Agreements
Trade and critical minerals were also part of President Trump's visit to China. He demanded that Beijing purchase higher quantities of agricultural products from American farmers. Yet, questions persisted surrounding various trade announcements. President Trump claimed a trade agreement was reached with Thailand, while both nations indicated that negotiations remained ongoing. Similarly, discrepancies surfaced between the public information released by the Philippine government and Trump's claims regarding a major trade deal announcement.
Ultimately, the true outcome of this summit was that it provided a shared platform for the world's three major superpowers. While principle agreements were reached on issues such as UN reforms, oil supplies, and nuclear threat dialogue, no concrete agreements materialized on major crises like the wars in Ukraine and Iran, nuclear arms control, or trade, while the ultimate success of this summit will depend entirely on the subsequent steps these three nations take to implement these declarations on the ground.